Stay Vs Go Analysis

Stay vs Go

Analysis:

The most important question your business will face about its property isn’t where to move but it’s whether to move at all. Most businesses approach a lease renewal with one of two assumptions: that they’ll stay because moving is too disruptive, or that they’ll move because the market has better options. Both are the wrong starting point.

Our Stay vs Go Analysis replaces assumption with evidence. We give CFOs, operations directors, and leadership teams the data and strategic clarity to make a confident, well-reasoned property decision before the clock runs out.

Sample Analysis Output

Current Rental vs Market Rate
R210 per m²
Space Utilisation Rate
85%
Projected Annual Saving (Stay & Renegotiate)
R985,000 (60 Months)

Recommendation

Stay & Renegotiate

The Challenge

Most businesses approach lease renewals with the wrong question.

The typical approach goes one of two ways. Either the business assumes it will stay because moving feels too disruptive and renews without ever testing what the market would give them. Or it assumes the market is better elsewhere and starts exploring options without any strategic framework to evaluate them.

That is exactly what the Stay vs Go Analysis answers. It is a structured, data-led advisory process that gives leadership teams the evidence and strategic clarity to make a confident, well-reasoned property decision before time pressure forces their hand.

What You Receive

Six deliverables.

One clear recommendation.

Every Stay vs Go Analysis produces a structured, executive-ready output, giving your leadership team everything needed to make a confident decision and act on it.

01

Rental Benchmark Report

A detailed comparison of your current rental rate against live market data in your node — including comparable buildings, achievable alternatives, and landlord incentive benchmarks such as tenant installation allowances and rent-free periods.

Our Flagship Service

The Stay vs Go Analysis.

The most important property decision your business will make isn’t choosing a new office, it’s knowing whether you should move at all. Our Stay vs Go Analysis gives leadership teams the data and strategic clarity to make that call with confidence.

Sample Analysis Output

Current Rental vs Market Rate
R210 per m²
Space Utilisation Rate
85%
Projected Annual Saving (Stay & Renegotiate)
R985,000 (60 Months)

Our Methodology

What we examine in every analysis.

Our advisory process examines eight critical dimensions of your property position. No assumption is left untested. No cost is left unmodelled.

Live Rental Benchmarking – Current achievable rates for comparable space in your node and adjacent nodes — drawn from active listings, recent transactions, and our own market intelligence.

Landlord Incentive Landscape – Tenant installation allowances, rent-free periods, and escalation benchmarks currently being offered in the market — giving you the full picture of what you could be negotiating for.

Lease Timing & Leverage Window – Exactly when your leverage is highest — and the critical deadlines that, if missed, will cost you negotiating power with your landlord.

Space Utilisation & Right-Sizing – How much space you are actually using versus paying for — and the financial opportunity created by right-sizing your footprint for hybrid working patterns.

Fit-Out & Relocation Cost Modelling – The true, fully-loaded cost of relocating — including fit-out, move costs, downtime, productivity impact, and any make-good obligations under your current lease.

Business Growth & Headcount Projections – Your space requirements over the full lease term — modelled against your business plan, hiring projections, and the flexibility you’ll need to accommodate growth or contraction.

Location & Operational Alignment – How well your current and alternative locations serve your staff, clients, suppliers, and operations — including access, transport links, and amenity benchmarks.

Building Grade & Specification – Whether your current building’s grade, specification, and ESG credentials meet your occupier standards — and whether the market can offer meaningfully better at a comparable cost.

Possible Outcomes

Three scenarios. One evidence-based answer.

Every Stay vs Go Analysis evaluates all three possible paths, giving your leadership team a complete, honest picture before committing to any direction.

Scenario A

Stay & Accept

Your current space and lease terms are competitive. The market offers limited upside and the cost and disruption of moving outweigh any potential benefit. The right move is staying and banking the certainty.

Typical signals

  • Rental rate is at or below market
  • Strong landlord relationship with track record
  • Fit-out recently completed or in good condition
  • Location is strongly embedded in operations

Scenario B

Stay & Renegotiate

Your location works but your lease terms don’t reflect the current market. Armed with our benchmarking data and the credible threat of relocation, we negotiate significantly improved terms, without the cost and risk of moving.

Typical signals

  • Rental rates above current achievable market rate
  • Insufficient re-furbishment allowance at last renewal
  • Escalation clause above market norm
  • Lease expiry is betwen 12–24 months away

Scenario C

Relocate

The data supports a move. Whether driven by cost, space requirements, business growth, or a market offering meaningfully better alternatives, relocation delivers the greatest long-term value, and we manage the entire process.

Typical signals

  • Significant space mismatch (too large or too small)
  • Location no longer serves operations or staff
  • Building grade below required standard
  • Market alternatives offer compelling cost saving

How It Works

Delivered in four stages, typically within 2–4 weeks.

Discovery & Strategic Brief

We begin with a structured briefing session with your CFO and operations leadership. We document your business strategy, growth trajectory, headcount projections, operational requirements, current lease details, and any constraints. This brief drives every subsequent analysis — ensuring the recommendation is built around your business, not a template.

When to Commission

The earlier you engage, the stronger your position.

Timing is the single most important factor in your negotiating leverage. Most businesses engage too late and pay for it in the terms they accept.

"The best time to start a Stay vs Go Analysis is the day you stop assuming your next lease renewal is a formality."

Corporate Real Estate Solutions

Common questions

Frequently asked questions.

  1. What is a Stay vs Go Analysis?
    A Stay vs Go Analysis is a structured advisory process that evaluates whether your business should renew and renegotiate its current lease, relocate to a new property, or right-size its existing space. It uses live rental benchmarks, occupancy data, total cost of occupancy modelling, and business alignment scoring to produce a clear, evidence-based recommendation delivered in an executive-ready report.
  2. When should I commission a Stay vs Go Analysis?
    Ideally 18 to 24 months before your lease expiry date. This gives you sufficient time to negotiate from a position of strength, properly evaluate market alternatives, and execute whichever strategy the analysis recommends — without being pressured by an imminent deadline. That said, even with 12 months remaining there is meaningful value in commissioning the analysis. If you have under 6 months, contact us immediately, we may still be able to improve your position.
  3. How long does the Stay vs Go Analysis take?
    Most engagements are completed and the recommendation delivered within 2 to 4 weeks, depending on the complexity of your portfolio and the number of scenarios modelled. For multi-site portfolios or larger, more complex occupancies, we will agree a detailed timeline at the outset. We do not rush the analysis but we do move efficiently, because timing matters in commercial property.
  4. Is the analysis genuinely independent?
    Yes — completely. Corporate Real Estate Solutions acts exclusively for the occupier. We have no relationship with any landlord, developer, property fund, or letting agency. We receive no commission from any landlord for any recommendation we make. Our only mandate is delivering the best possible outcome for you and our fee structure reflects that. This independence is fundamental to the integrity of the analysis.
  5. What does a Stay vs Go Analysis cost?
    Advisory fees are structured based on the scope of the engagement and the size of your lease obligation. In the vast majority of cases, the rental savings and improved terms we identify far outweigh the advisory fee, often by a multiple of 5 to 15 times over the lease term. We are happy to provide a fee proposal after an initial no-obligation conversation about your situation.
  6. What happens after the analysis — do you help with execution?
    Yes. The Stay vs Go Analysis is the strategic foundation, execution is where the recommendation is turned into results. If the analysis recommends renegotiating, we move immediately into lease negotiation on your behalf. If it recommends relocating, we lead the full tenant representation process identifying and shortlisting alternatives, negotiating terms, and managing the transaction through to completion. You don’t have to find another advisor.
  7. We already have an internal property team. Do we still need this?
    Often, yes. Internal property teams are expert in their own portfolio but typically don’t have access to live market transaction data, current landlord incentive benchmarks, or the negotiating intelligence that comes from active market participation. We frequently work alongside internal teams, providing the external market intelligence and independent benchmarking that makes their work more effective, and their negotiations more credible.

Get Started

Ready to make your
next property decision
with confidence?

Whether your lease is expiring in 6 months or 3 years, the best time to engage a CRE advisor is earlier than you think. Let’s start with a no-obligation strategy call.

Prefer to call?

+27 61 484 5578

Long Street
City Center, Cape Town
South Africa

Related Services

Where the analysis leads next.

Lease Negotiation & Renewal

We negotiate directly with your landlord on your behalf, securing improved rental rates, enhanced TIA, extended rent-free periods, and more favourable escalation and option clause

Read More

Tenant Representation Services

We act exclusively in your interest to identify, evaluate, and negotiate the best available premises in your target market, managing the full transaction from brief to handover.

Read More

Stay Versus Go Analysis for Commercial Property Occupiers

One of the most important commercial real estate decisions a business will make is whether to remain in its current premises or relocate to a new property. The decision affects far more than rental costs. It influences operational efficiency, employee experience, client accessibility, workplace performance, business continuity, and long-term growth strategy. A poorly timed or poorly informed decision can create unnecessary financial exposure and operational disruption. A well-structured decision can reduce costs, improve productivity, and position the business more effectively for future growth. A Stay Versus Go Analysis provides businesses with a structured framework for evaluating both options objectively. Rather than making decisions based on assumptions, pressure from lease deadlines, or limited market visibility, the analysis creates a detailed comparison between staying in the current premises and relocating elsewhere. The goal is to identify which option delivers the strongest operational and financial outcome for the business over both the short and long term.

Many businesses reach a critical decision point when a lease expiry approaches. In many cases, the existing premises no longer align with operational requirements. The business may have outgrown the space, reduced staff numbers, adopted hybrid working models, or experienced changes in workflow and departmental structure. In other situations, the premises may still function operationally, but the lease terms no longer reflect current market conditions. Rental costs may have become uncompetitive, the building may require upgrades, or the workplace may no longer support staff expectations.

Stay Versus Go Analysis

Without a structured review process, businesses often default to the easiest option. Some renew leases without testing the market, potentially locking themselves into unfavourable terms for another lease cycle. Others relocate too quickly without fully understanding the total cost and operational impact of moving. Both approaches create avoidable risk. A Stay Versus Go Analysis removes emotion and assumption from the process and replaces it with measurable commercial analysis.

If you are planning to move your business, check out the latest offices to Rent in Century City

The first stage of the analysis involves understanding the business itself. Property decisions should always support wider business objectives. We assess operational requirements, workforce structure, growth forecasts, departmental interactions, technology requirements, client-facing needs, and long-term strategic direction. A business planning significant expansion may require flexibility for future growth. A business adopting hybrid work strategies may require less space but higher-quality collaborative environments. A logistics-driven company may prioritise access to transport infrastructure and operational efficiency over location prestige. Once operational requirements are understood, we conduct a detailed review of the current premises. This includes analysing lease terms, occupancy costs, operational performance, space utilisation, parking ratios, building quality, workplace efficiency, infrastructure capabilities, and potential constraints within the existing property. We identify strengths, weaknesses, and any operational limitations affecting the business.

This website and branding services designed by Webspace Design and Marketing Services

Occupancy cost analysis forms a major component of the process. Many businesses focus only on base rental rates when evaluating property decisions. In reality, total occupancy costs extend far beyond rent. Operating expenses, parking charges, municipal increases, energy consumption, maintenance obligations, tenant installation costs, reinstatement liabilities, and future rental escalations all influence the long-term financial position of the occupier. A Stay Versus Go Analysis evaluates the full financial picture rather than isolated cost components.

Read more about our Tenant Representation Services

If remaining in the existing premises is being considered, we assess the potential for renegotiating lease terms with the landlord. This may include rental reductions, increased tenant installation allowances, improved lease flexibility, reduced escalations, expansion rights, space reconfiguration opportunities, or incentives linked to lease renewals. In many cases, landlords are prepared to negotiate aggressively to retain quality tenants and avoid vacancy risk. Understanding landlord positioning and current market conditions creates leverage during these negotiations. At the same time, we conduct a detailed review of alternative properties available within the market. This includes identifying buildings that align with the occupier’s operational requirements, budget parameters, workforce considerations, branding objectives, and long-term growth plans. We compare available relocation opportunities against the existing premises to determine whether moving would create measurable operational or financial advantages.

The analysis includes direct financial modelling between staying and relocating. This provides businesses with clear visibility into the true cost implications of each option over the proposed lease term. Relocation costs can be substantial and often extend beyond the property transaction itself. Moving costs may include fit-out expenses, technology migration, infrastructure upgrades, downtime risk, legal fees, project management costs, furniture procurement, reinstatement obligations, branding updates, and operational disruption. These factors must be evaluated alongside rental comparisons to create an accurate assessment.

Find out more about renting offices in Tygervalley

A Stay Versus Go Analysis also considers workplace performance and employee experience. Workplace strategy has become increasingly important as businesses compete for talent and adapt to changing workforce expectations. Accessibility, public transport connectivity, parking availability, surrounding amenities, workspace quality, collaborative areas, wellness considerations, and overall workplace environment all influence employee satisfaction and productivity. The right workplace supports recruitment, retention, and operational culture. The wrong workplace creates friction and inefficiency. Technology and infrastructure requirements also play a major role in modern occupancy decisions. Businesses increasingly require buildings capable of supporting high-speed connectivity, backup power solutions, sustainability objectives, security systems, and flexible workspace configurations. Older buildings may struggle to accommodate evolving operational requirements without significant upgrades. Part of the analysis involves evaluating whether the current premises can continue supporting future operational needs effectively. Timing is another critical factor. Property markets shift continuously based on supply levels, economic conditions, vacancy trends, and development pipelines. Businesses approaching lease expiries without sufficient lead time often lose negotiating leverage and reduce their available options. We recommend beginning a Stay Versus Go Analysis well in advance of critical lease events to allow enough time for strategic planning, market testing, negotiations, and implementation if relocation becomes the preferred outcome.

Read more about our Office Renovation Services in Cape Town

Flexibility has become increasingly valuable within commercial real estate strategy. Many businesses no longer want rigid long-term lease structures that limit operational adaptability. A Stay Versus Go Analysis evaluates how each option supports future flexibility. This includes assessing expansion potential, contraction rights, lease break options, hybrid workplace adaptability, and long-term portfolio scalability. The objective is to ensure the property strategy supports future business changes rather than restricting them.

The process also helps businesses identify hidden opportunities within the market. In some cases, occupiers discover they can secure higher-quality premises at comparable occupancy costs due to changing market conditions. In other situations, businesses realise their current location still offers the strongest operational value once relocation costs and disruption are properly accounted for. The analysis creates transparency around both outcomes.

One of the most valuable aspects of a Stay Versus Go Analysis is the negotiating leverage it creates. Landlords negotiate differently when they know occupiers are actively evaluating alternative options. Businesses that enter renewal discussions with detailed market data, financial analysis, and relocation comparisons place themselves in a significantly stronger position. Even if the preferred outcome is to remain in the existing premises, the process often leads to improved commercial terms and greater lease flexibility.

Operational continuity remains a key consideration throughout the analysis. Relocations affect staff, clients, suppliers, and internal systems. Some businesses can absorb relocation disruption relatively easily. Others operate within environments where downtime or operational interruptions create major financial and reputational risks. We evaluate these operational realities carefully to ensure the recommended strategy supports business continuity requirements. Our Corporate Services team manages the Stay Versus Go process from initial assessment through to final implementation. If remaining in the current premises becomes the preferred outcome, we lead lease negotiations and renewal strategy discussions with the landlord. If relocation delivers the stronger result, we manage property sourcing, transaction negotiations, project coordination, and relocation planning to ensure the process remains controlled and aligned with operational timelines.

Stay Versus Go Analysis in Rea Estate

Every business faces different pressures, priorities, and growth patterns. There is no universal answer to whether a company should stay or relocate. The right decision depends on operational strategy, financial considerations, market conditions, workforce requirements, and long-term business objectives. A structured Stay Versus Go Analysis provides the clarity needed to make that decision with confidence. Commercial real estate should support business performance rather than create operational constraints. Businesses that regularly reassess their property strategy place themselves in stronger positions financially and operationally. Waiting until lease expiry pressure forces a rushed decision usually leads to compromised outcomes. Strategic planning creates leverage, flexibility, and access to better opportunities.

We help businesses approach occupancy decisions strategically, objectively, and commercially. Our Stay Versus Go Analysis services provide the insight, financial modelling, market intelligence, and negotiation expertise needed to evaluate all available options properly. Whether the outcome involves renewing an existing lease, restructuring occupancy costs, relocating operations, or repositioning a wider property portfolio, our focus remains the same: helping occupiers make property decisions that support long-term business success.

Whether you’re looking to expand your footprint, optimize your current space, or navigate complex lease negotiations, we have the knowledge and experience to help you achieve your goals.

Contact Info

© 2026 Created by: Website Design & Marketing